No Fault Vs At Fault

Learn about No Fault Vs At Fault and your legal options after an accident.

Where an accident happens has a major effect on how a claim works. States generally fall into one of two systems for handling car accident injuries: no-fault or at-fault (also called tort) systems. Knowing which type of state applies to a crash shapes everything from where the initial claim is filed to whether a lawsuit against the other driver is even an option.

No Fault Vs At Fault image
Clear records and early action improve claim outcomes.

How No-Fault States Work

In no-fault states, which number around a dozen across the country, each driver's own insurance company generally pays for their medical expenses and certain other losses through Personal Injury Protection, or PIP, coverage, regardless of who caused the accident. The idea behind no-fault systems is to get medical bills paid quickly without waiting for a determination of fault.

However, no-fault does not mean an injured person can never pursue the at-fault driver. Most no-fault states include a tort threshold, a legal standard that must be met before someone can step outside the no-fault system and bring a claim directly against the at-fault driver. This threshold is often based on either the severity of the injury, such as a serious injury definition covering permanent impairment, disfigurement, or death, or a dollar amount of medical expenses. Meeting the threshold matters significantly, since it determines whether pain and suffering damages become available at all.

How At-Fault States Work

In at-fault, or tort, states, the driver responsible for causing the accident, and by extension their insurance company, is generally liable for the injured party's damages. An injured person in an at-fault state can typically file a claim directly against the at-fault driver's liability insurance, or pursue a lawsuit, without needing to meet a special injury threshold first. This generally makes it more straightforward to pursue full compensation, including pain and suffering, from the start.

Were you rear-ended by another driver?

Find out how much compensation you may be entitled to.

What to Do Next

Find out whether your state follows a no-fault or at-fault system, since it determines where you file first and what you may need to show to pursue full compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Around a dozen states use some version of no-fault insurance, though the details vary by state. In these states, your own insurer generally pays your medical bills through Personal Injury Protection coverage regardless of who caused the crash. The goal is faster payment of medical costs without waiting for a fault determination. The remaining states use an at-fault, or tort, system, where the driver who caused the crash is generally liable for the other person's damages.

Generally, no. PIP is built to cover medical expenses and some lost wages regardless of fault, not pain and suffering. To pursue pain and suffering in a no-fault state, you typically have to meet that state's tort threshold first, based on either injury severity or a medical cost amount. Until that threshold is met, a claim usually stays inside the no-fault system and is limited to the categories PIP actually covers.

It is the standard that determines when someone in a no-fault state can step outside their own PIP coverage and pursue the at-fault driver directly. Thresholds are typically based on either how serious the injury is, such as permanent impairment or disfigurement, or how much has been spent on medical treatment. Meeting the threshold is what opens the door to pain and suffering damages. Check your specific state's definition, since the standard is not identical everywhere.

Generally, yes, and without needing to clear a special injury threshold first. At-fault states place liability directly on the driver who caused the crash, so an injured person can typically file against that driver's liability insurance or pursue a claim in court from the outset. That makes the path to full compensation, including pain and suffering, more direct than in a no-fault state, though fault still has to be established with evidence.

Get the Compensation You Deserve

Our experienced rear-end collision attorneys are ready to fight for you. No fee unless you win.

Call Now Free Review